Planning the perfect product
Whether it’s chopping and changing, remoulding or building something
new from scratch, designers of products for the wealth management
industry have their work cut out for them. Paula Garrido and Yuri Bender report.
Identifying the next top-performing asset class, the most profitable
industrial sector or the region with the best potential for growth is
only the first step of the product development process. Designing
wholesale products that will allow investors to access those markets,
and adapting them for each separate distribution model is what can
really make the difference for a manufacturer or distributor.
Distributors looking to set up a comprehensive buy-list may appear
spoilt for choice. After all, they have access to traditional European,
US and Asian equity classes, absolute return, private equity, the more
colourful fixed income strategies such as high yield, and exposure to
emerging regions.
But in reality, it is a small number of sectors that are driving
performance, leading to a re-think in asset allocation philosophy and
the types of products that are chosen for private clients. The
disappointing performance of the equity markets in recent years has
forced asset managers to look for different and more sophisticated
investment vehicles where risk management and portfolio diversification
are crucial. And, building the new breed of product in a way to allow
the manufacturer and distributor to skim off enough fat while leaving a
meaningful return for the investor is possibly the greatest challenge
faced by the industry.
Returns vs charges
“We have to ask ourselves – where is the retail value proposition
today?” says Alan Brown, group chief investment officer at State Street
Global Advisors, responsible for investing assets of $1,100bn (e900bn)
“In a world of double-digit returns you could take 5 per cent upfront,
charge 1.5 per cent per annum and another 1 per cent of transaction
costs and still leave something on the table.
“But in a world of single-digit gross returns you can’t levy those
charges and leave anything worthwhile for the investor. How can the
industry respond?”
It is a challenge to which product design boffins have not been slow to
rise. They have wheeled out their latest risk control models, regional
databanks and asset class experts to be one step ahead of the
competition.
Or they are able to delve deep into the product store, and dust down,
adapt and re-market some old favourites which have come back into vogue
due to changing economic conditions.
Credit Suisse Asset Management (CSAM) uses both these approaches, as it
has a huge incentive to stay ahead of the pack. It manufactures for a
captive internal private banking channel, for an increasing army of
internal distributors and has a huge institutional franchise from which
the best strategies can be adapted.
Its analysts and asset managers have also been keeping a watching brief
on latest economic developments in Europe, so they are ready to move
quickly when the opportunity presents itself.
One of these opportunities is the accession on May 1 of eight new
countries – the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania,
Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia – to the European Union. Along with Malta
and Cyprus, these nations will boost the EU from 15 to 25 members.
Although their economies have already converged, their accession could attract more interest from investors.
“There are four ways to invest in these regions that are very
attractive propositions,” says Jana Benesova, director and fixed income
portfolio manager at CSAM, giving an insight into how the product
design decisions are made.
Benesova: four ways to invest
“The first one is to invest into fixed income funds that benefit from
all the movements that are part of the convergence process.”
This ground has been previously covered by the Credit Suisse Bond Fund
Emerging Europe (Lux), which has attracted E162m, invested in debt
securities primarily issued by governments, government agencies and
corporations in Central, Southern and Eastern Europe.
Now the fund is once again being pushed through the distribution channels, as the EU enlargement story reaches its climax.
Heaviest weight
Benchmarked against the Merrill Lynch Emerging European Government
Bond index, the cross-border fund has its heaviest weightings in
Poland, Hungary and the Russian Federation, concentrating on bonds with
a maturity of up to five years.
“The second proposition,” says Ms Benesova, “is to invest in a Central European equity fund.”
“But people should take into account that some of those funds include
Russia and Turkey in their benchmark, so investors need to be aware
that they are also buying into a region which is not converging,” she
warns.
“The third proposition is going into the real estate market, which I
think is very attractive but again there are legal differences across
the countries that need to be taken into account. Finally, the fourth
option is to invest in private equity in the region and you can find
several firms that are looking into that.”
The New Europe Emerging Cities fund, launched in February by UK firm
Guardian Managers is an example of the real estate opportunities in the
region.
The initial focus is on investments in commercial property in major
cities in Central and Eastern Europe, particularly within new EU member
states, but the fund will also consider opportunities in Romania,
Bulgaria, Serbia, Russia, Greece and some principal cities in the
former East Germany. Designed for investors seeking a longer term
holding, the fund aims to attract interest from private banks and
insurance companies, as well as larger retail investment portfolios.
Areas of activity
London private client house Cazenove sees these property-based
products as an increasing area of activity for wealthy investors, along
with uncorrelated investments, such as hedge funds in particular. It
has created two relatively low-risk long-short funds and is debating
how to adapt its Absolute Return Fund for Charities, a low volatility
multi-manager fund advised by Fauchier Partners, which gained 12.3 per
cent last year, for high net worth clients.
One way of doing this is to add a guarantee for clients weary of years
of poor equity returns. Man Investments, the world’s largest hedge fund
player, has been developing products that invest across different
investment styles, aiming to achieve portfolio diversification with
guaranteed returns.
Launched in February, the portfolio of the Man RMF Multi-Style fund
consists of five complementary hedge fund styles – equity hedged, event
driven, global macro, managed futures and relative value – with the aim
to perform independently of traditional stock and bond investments.
James Jacklin, senior manager at Man Investments, explains that the
strength of this new investment vehicle is its potential to add
diversification and enhance risk/return profile of investors’
portfolios.
Return guaranteed
The protection structure guarantees a return of at least 100 per
cent of the initial investment on maturity, and a profit-lock feature
offers the potential to elevate the guarantee level at maturity by
locking in a proportion of net new trading profits, following periods
of sustained profitability.
Jacklin: protection structure in place
“The fund is available for both institutional and private investors and
it’s the first of the four structured products we will be
launching throughout the year,” says Mr Jacklin.
Leading European funds house DWS has been quick to adapt hedge funds
for the domestic German market. This is in response to German
regulations driven by a political decision, at cabinet level, intended
to boost long-term investments.
DWS is using the New York arm of parent company Deutsche Bank to run
single manager hedge funds, and to help select 30 underlying external
advisers for its multi-manager offering.
Competitors, including Swiss banks, have been reluctant to enter this
potentially lucrative market due to onerous transparency requirements
of the German regulators. There has long been a bizarre tradition among
private banks where not just positions but even names of underlying
managers are kept secret from clients.
“We cannot produce 30 strategies internally,” says Axel Benkner, chief
executive of DWS. “So we need to appoint external managers, which
necessitates research and evaluation. So that we can access 30 managers
in different companies in a short period of time, we use Deutsche Bank
as our co-operation partner.
“We will not have a problem with transparency,” says Mr Benkner. “We
have never faced a group who did not want to share information with us.
This is because they want to sell their funds. They see us moving ahead
and selling funds in billions, so they are prepared to do the admin
work. We treat data confidentially and will not abuse it for
front-running.”
Tools for managing risk are also becoming more sophisticated and
efficient, and are now essential for fund managers, distributors and
clients.
Risk model
Goldman Sachs has gone a step further by developing its risk model
in line with its CORE (computer-optimised, research-enhanced) strategy.
Now it is targeting distributors with this institutional-style strategy.
Brown: institutional-style strategy
Melissa Brown, managing director at Goldman Sachs Asset Management’s
global quantitative team says: “Our CORE risk model reacts more quickly
to changing levels and sources of risk by using daily returns as
opposed to monthly returns. We think it estimates the risk in our
process more accurately because it takes into account factors which are
specific to our investment process.”
A good example of their CORE investment products is the GS US CORE
Equity Portfolio fund that managed to attract more than $700m in 2003,
now boasting $1bn assets under management. Its European equivalent, the
GS Europe CORE Equity Portfolio, has also been successful in 2003,
attracting over $130m in assets. Currently the fund has a size of
$207m. The funds follow strategies which combine traditional investment
management practices with quantitative criteria.
de Vijlder: trust is most important
“Theoretically, there is always the danger that a product is designed
for the benefit of the house, not the client,” admits William de
Vijlder, chief investment officer responsible for over E80bn at Fortis
Investments in Brussels. “What is of the utmost importance is that the
relationship with clients is based on trust, and identifies issues and
solutions. It should not be a case of ‘I have this product, and you
have to buy it.’ Solutions must relate to the risk exposure of clients.”
A love story to warm the hearts of investors in Bollywood films
The private equity market has been targeting high net worth individuals
for some time, but when new investment proposals come with the magic
“tax relief” tag attached to them, the attraction can be instant.
In the UK, a new scheme has been launched to invest in the booming
Bollywood film industry. The scheme, Motion Pictures Partners
International (MPPI), is a series of partnerships established to
provide up to Ł34m for the production and acquisition of the UK/Indian
films while creating tax incentives for its partners.
MPPI is working on the production of 10 films currently being made in the UK and India, using facilities in Leicester.
Tax relief
MPPI will use secured borrowing to leverage partners’ capital, allowing
funding of more films, and providing partners with an increase in the
initial tax relief available from 40 to 140 per cent of their capital
contribution. In order for the films to qualify for tax relief, a
minimum of 70 per cent of the total budget should be spent in the UK.
Rajeev Saxena, founding partner at MPPI, says: “This is a fantastic
opportunity for UK investors to participate in the most vibrant film
market in the world. New structural developments such as the increase
in multiplex theatres and the emergence of cable TV have increased
access in both the Indian domestic market and for the non-resident
Indian population.”
He says MMPI has managed to attract interest from wealthy investors through independent advisers and “personal contacts”.
“Together with the up-front tax relief, minimum guaranteed revenues and
potential for additional profits, MPPI offers a very attractive and, to
our knowledge, a unique combination for partners,” believes Mr Saxena.
“The Indian economy is booming and this is having an impact in
Bollywood movies and local communities in the UK. Under the scheme,
tax-payers become co-producers of films in an industry that is becoming
more westernised.”
New rules
The MPPI initiative comes against the background of an announcement
from the UK Inland Revenue about the introduction of new rules to avoid
tax relief abuses in some film partnerships. MPPI’s scheme type will
not be affected by the new rules, but other film investment schemes may
have to change the way they develop in the future. For the time being
at least, Leicester remains the UK’s capital of Indian entertainment.